The B-book brokerage model also has a number of undeniable advantages, which are as follows. No business model, including the A-Book and B-Book models, can guarantee a successful firm or a lucrative transaction. These models are only tools for doing business, and the extent to which you gain personally from them is solely dependent on your ability to apply them in a professional manner. At that, nobody knows how aggressively the B-Book broker will bleed its customers dry.
The ECN system is another market participant, an intermediary providing the technological ability to process orders. The broker can create its own ECN system, but then it becomes senseless, as there will be a relatively small number of participants. Moreover, the A-Book and B-Book models utilize different technologies of order execution, depending on the https://www.xcritical.com/ sub-type, MM, NDD, STP, ECN, DMA, MTF. The broker would just constantly make money from the spread (and overnight financing charges) and not have to worry about going bust. However, brokers don’t have just one customer, they have many. Brokers appeared with the emergence of the stock exchange, the place where buying and selling of securities occurs.
Top 10 Trading & Market Structure Reads
We come to the conclusion that none of the plans can be considered a cure for loss. After considering your company objectives and strategies, you must pick which business model is best for you to implement. A similar argument may be made for traders who choose their broker.
A market maker is often a synonym for the B-Book Forex broker. This scenario involves a broker trading against his customers. The broker does not use an external liquidity pool to carry out deals; instead, the business serves as a counterparty to the trader’s transactions. Essentially, a broker will sell to a trader who makes a buy order and vice versa.
A-Book model is the business model of a broker where all trader’s orders are forwarded directly to the forex liquidity provider, who then redirects them to the interbank market. As for prohibiting inducements – this just means that brokers can no longer incentivize traders to trade more actively through offering prizes and gifts. Any broker that encourages you to take undue risk by trading larger or more frequently than you normally would is almost certainly a B-book broker who is profiting from your losses. If you are trading through a B-book trader and your account goes into the negative, it really means nothing.
Look at the fees related to these accounts as well – it makes their trading conditions a little worse than that of other accounts. Forex is the only market where a broker can trade against you by using a bookmaker-like model. It’s simply impossible to do this in other markets due to a regulator. Since your broker makes money if you lose money, there exists a potential conflict of interest. Last week I withdrew all of my money from all of my Oanda accounts and moved them into Global Prime, and the process was practically seamless.
To avoid the shortcomings of the A-Book and B-Book schemes, brokers came up with a hybrid model. Hybrid model means that the broker executes small transactions within its platform, while large transactions can be withdrawn to the liquidity provider and then to the interbank. I wouldn’t say that the STP or the DMA are the best forex broker models. Every model has its pros and cons, in terms of order execution speed, trading costs and slippages. I would recommend trying both models and choosing the one most suitable for your trading style and trading system.
Forex B-Book model
A-Book forex brokers make their profits via a small mark up on the spread/commission that you directly pay when placing trading orders. Assume the spread from the liquidity provider is 3 pips, your A Book broker may list it on their platform as 4 pips, guaranteeing them a 1 pip profit. The broker needs to sign agreements with a liquidity provider (or with several of them), obtain licenses, provide technical support to bring client orders to the external market. Accordingly, the A-Book broker is forced to increase the mark-up to the spread to justify its costs.
Retail traders tend to act like gamblers, and a B-Book broker acts as the “house”. The only long-term methodology to beat the markets is to implement an algorithmic momentum strategy that extracts inefficiencies from the market simply by the existence of volatility, regardless of whether it is bearish or bullish. In spot trading, Interactive is the most professional option and possibly the best retail broker ever created. If you are a winning trader, this is where your trades will go. Let’s find out what is the notion of liquidity risk, why should a trader get his orders executed instantly, and how to find and pick a reliable LP. As a hard-working, goal-oriented, and well-rounded person, I always strive to do quality work for every job I do.
So while I think it’s a bit of an over-reaction to the problem, it does make it harder for B-book brokers to let their clients blow up. Therefore, dishonest brokers may be interested in setting non-market quotes in the terminal, spying on the set client stops and knocking them down with plugins in the server side of the platform to make the trader lose money. Unfortunately, there are many such “bucket shop” brokerage companies, but we won’t dwell on this — we analyze forex brokers, not scammers.
A-Book vs. B-Book Brokers
A big question regarding B-book models is why financial regulators allow them to operate at all. But in any case – even if you don’t have access to high leverage, if your broker profits from your losses, then they have no incentive to help you educate yourself and get better at trading. It is a licensed, regulated broker working on the A-Book hybrid model. Traders have a choice between classic trading accounts (Classic, STP model) and professional ECN accounts. Therefore, the broker is forced to use software to track such tricks of the provider. According to representatives of a large brokerage company, this practice occurs even at the “highest Forex levels”. Sometimes it is enough to inform the provider about the breach of contract. Sometimes brokers have to look for a new provider.
- If you are a winning trader, this is where your trades will go.
- Many retail traders, especially those new to trading, typically have no idea what good “risk management” looks like.
- If a broker has just one customer and uses B-Book execution, then obviously, it wouldn’t want the trades that its ONLY customer makes to win.
- That way, you avoid being a winning trader in the B-book, which is the biggest fear of all brokers in financial derivatives.
- If you think of a B-Book broker like a casino, it doesn’t want a customer that trades so big that any individual bet exposes the broker to so much market risk that it could cause it to “go bust” or “take the house down”.
For example, you can set it up so that your CEO will be making final approval of withdrawal requests of certain big amounts. You can set up this rule for all requests or only for those that are already approved by lower-ranking staff. It is very important to verify your client with a KYC check, confirm payment details, to do this just direct all requests through a Compliance department.
One could argue that it’s not the broker’s responsibility to educate their clients on how to trade. We all make our own decisions, and it’s our own responsibility to inform ourselves and educate ourselves on the risks we take. The report revealed that in 2018 over $2 billion was lost in binary options a book broker meaning & CFDs in the Australian retail trading industry – and this equated almost perfectly to the revenue of those brokers over that same time period. But ECN/STP brokers cannot be called pure ECN brokers, since they do not give the trader information about the Depth of Market (its liquidity).
A-Book vs B-Book: What’s the Difference and How They Make Money
I even have my automated PineConnector scripts trading through my new Global Prime MetaTrader account – and it’s already up +3%. This is really the main reason why you should care if your broker is a B-book or A-book broker. Interestingly enough, the actual difference between the products offered by an A-book and B-book broker are not that big. So long as brokers are allowed to directly profit from trading against their clients, there is a huge conflict of interest.
DMA is similar to STP, where traders’ orders are distributed among liquidity providers. Conversely, in the STP model, the trader has to match the offer of a particular liquidity provider (only the one with which the broker has an agreement). You can learn more about Forex trades processing mechanisms, types of order execution, such as Market Execution and Instant Execution, as well as the A-Book and B-Book models in this article. I will deal in more detail with the principles of transactions transfer to the interbank market based on the A-Book model and the hybrid scheme. Most new retail traders have no trading experience and it’s not uncommon for 80-90% of them to lose their entire deposit within 12 months. In this A-book, the broker/exchange generates revenue through spreads, swaps, maker/taker fees, and/or other optional services, such as guaranteed stop losses to prevent slippage.
Brokers “B-Book” trades because it’s usually more profitable for them. If a broker wants to “STP’ or “A-Book”, it also has to pay a spread to an LP to hedge your trade. When you open a trade with a B-Book forex broker, the broker takes the other side of your trade and does not hedge. Even if I am not an introducing broker, in the OTC derivatives arena (mainly CFDs) brokers like Global Prime, CMC, IG, Tradeview, or Saxo can guarantee you a quality A-book if you have a winning algorithmic strategy. Although PFOF execution is not as extreme as B-book model execution in the OTC derivatives space or in the blockchain ecosystem, it is banned in Canada and the UK, but is widely legal in the EU, Australasia, the US, and almost all Emerging Markets. Ask them by email to show you which LPs they deal with and see how they respond.